[Moose-dev] Re: PhaMoose and Moose-All dependencies in monticello

I wonder if we could not refactor the dependencies between the required packages in Moose-All. Because it starts to look like a big ball of mud. Granted we will soon have the tools (with Jannik) to get a better comprehension of that but here it is: Moose-all required packages: Moose-Core-jannik_laval.128, Moose-GenericImporter-simon_denier.laval.26, Moose-LAN-jannik_laval.8, <========= test and resources Moose-SmalltalkImporter-jannik_laval.ducasse.58, Moose-ModelTest-simon_denier.26, <========= test and resources Moose-ConformityStrategies-simon_denier.9, Famix-Core-Alexandre_Bergel.84, Famix-Implementation-simon_denier.37, Famix-Smalltalk-simon_denier.23, Famix-File-Alexandre_Bergel.15, EMOF-stephane.ducasse.1, <======= this one should be removed Moose-Test-PackageTwo-simon_denier.ducasse.3, <========= test and resources Moose-ReferenceModel-stephane_ducasse.ducasse.15, <========= test and resources Moose-Test-PackageOne-stephane.ducasse.2, <========= test and resources Famix-SmalltalkImporter-simon_denier.81, Famix-LANTests-simon_denier.ducasse.22, <========= test and resources CollectionExtensions-simon_denier.14, Famix-Extensions-simon_denier.42, Moose-File-Alexandre_Bergel.9, <========= test and resources Moose-CookFamix3-simon_denier.18, Moose-OBBrowser-simon_denier.50, Moose-MondrianScripts-simon_denier.32, <==== require MondrianExtensions and Mondrian Moose-Hismo-simon_denier.12, Famix-Test-simon_denier.4, <========= test and resources Famix-SourceAnchor-tg.5, Moose-MonticelloImporter-Alexandre_Bergel.7, Moose-Finder-tg.28, <========= needs Glamour project Moose also needs (but does not 'require') Fame project, Nile, Smacc, RB, Omnibrowser, RIO for some extensions, and perhaps other things we are not really aware of... This is a lot... In line with the current effort to better the MooseLoader, here is my proposal for refactoring moose dependencies. I distinguish between: - external dependencies to external projects (Fame, Mondrian, Glamour...) - managed by MooseLoader load scripts - internal dependencies aka required packages for a single project - managed by Monticello internal mechanisms - hidden dependencies, which should be removed as soon as identified :) *Moose-Basic* The goal is to have a minimal footprint moose image, for performing batch operations, importing big projects, exporting big MSE, etc, without relying on a browser. It can also serve as a basis for people who want to customize their moose image (like Jannik or I do, loading DSM after loading moose...) external: Nile, Fame, Smacc (to be removed?), RBSmallDictionary internal: Moose-Core-jannik_laval.128, Moose-GenericImporter-simon_denier.laval.26, Moose-SmalltalkImporter-jannik_laval.ducasse.58, Moose-ConformityStrategies-simon_denier.9, Famix-Core-Alexandre_Bergel.84, Famix-Implementation-simon_denier.37, Famix-Smalltalk-simon_denier.23, Famix-SmalltalkImporter-simon_denier.81, CollectionExtensions-simon_denier.14, Famix-Extensions-simon_denier.42, Famix-SourceAnchor-tg.5, borderline: Famix-File-Alexandre_Bergel.15, Moose-CookFamix3-simon_denier.18, *Moose-Basic-Tests* (actually tests and resources package require a refactoring of their own, as some are tangled and others are rather empty) internal: Moose-Basic Moose-LAN-jannik_laval.8, <========= test and resources Moose-ModelTest-simon_denier.26, <========= test and resources Moose-Test-PackageTwo-simon_denier.ducasse.3, <========= test and resources Moose-ReferenceModel-stephane_ducasse.ducasse.15, <========= test and resources Moose-Test-PackageOne-stephane.ducasse.2, <========= test and resources Famix-LANTests-simon_denier.ducasse.22, <========= test and resources Moose-File-Alexandre_Bergel.9, <========= test and resources Famix-Test-simon_denier.4, <========= test and resources *Moose-All* A complete distribution of Moose-related stable things for most usage. external: Mondrian, Glamour, Omnibrowser (at least for know), RIO... internal: Moose-Basic (Moose-Basic-Tests) Moose-OBBrowser-simon_denier.50, Moose-MondrianScripts-simon_denier.32, <==== require MondrianExtensions and Mondrian Moose-Hismo-simon_denier.12, Moose-MonticelloImporter-Alexandre_Bergel.7, Moose-Finder-tg.28, <========= needs Glamour project Anyone has something to say? -- Simon _______________________________________________ Moose-dev mailing list Moose-dev(a)iam.unibe.ch https://www.iam.unibe.ch/mailman/listinfo/moose-dev