29 Aug
2013
29 Aug
'13
1:12 a.m.
While trying to map Delphi to FAMIX, we ran into some issues:
- Delphi has definitions of a.o. methods split over the interface and
the implementation part of a unit. Where do I put the second sourcetextanchor?
This might be similar to the situation with c header files.
- Being a hybrid of structured and oo, functions seem to be best modeled as
scopingentities too. What does it mean that scopingentities represent an entity
defining a scope at a global level? Units in Delphi can be local to another unit.
- The class comment of behaviouralentity is a bit sloppy in describing which
metrics we should provide: is cylomatic complexity, numberOfStatements &
numberOfConditionals enough?
I am not sure I like the deep inheritance hierarchy of FAMIX. It seems
rather brittle. Is Delphi a special case?
Stephan
29 Aug
29 Aug
6:56 a.m.
Hi,
On Thu, Aug 29, 2013 at 1:12 AM, Stephan Eggermont <stephan(a)stack.nl> wrote:
While trying to map Delphi to FAMIX, we ran into some
issues:
- Delphi has definitions of a.o. methods split over the interface and
the implementation part of a unit. Where do I put the second
sourcetextanchor?
This might be similar to the situation with c header files.
The source anchor should point to the implementation, not the definition.
Perhaps for the definition, you can add a FAMIXDelphiMethodDefinition and
link it with a FAMIXMethod. This one then can have its own source anchor.
- Being a hybrid of structured and oo, functions seem
to be best modeled as
scopingentities too. What does it mean that scopingentities represent an
entity
defining a scope at a global level? Units in Delphi can be local to
another unit.
I do not understand this part. Could you provide more details and maybe an
example?
- The class comment of behaviouralentity is a bit
sloppy in describing
which
metrics we should provide: is cylomatic complexity, numberOfStatements &
numberOfConditionals enough?
You should provide those metrics that are not marked as derived. To find
this out you can evaluate:
FAMIXBehaviouralEntity asMooseDescription allAttributes select: [ :each |
each isDerived not and: [ each type = FM3 number ] ]
==>
an Array(
a FM3PropertyDescription[FAMIX.BehaviouralEntity.numberOfParameters]
a FM3PropertyDescription[FAMIX.BehaviouralEntity.numberOfStatements]
a FM3PropertyDescription[FAMIX.BehaviouralEntity.cyclomaticComplexity]
a FM3PropertyDescription[FAMIX.BehaviouralEntity.numberOfConditionals]
a FM3PropertyDescription[FAMIX.BehaviouralEntity.numberOfLinesOfCode]
a FM3PropertyDescription[FAMIX.BehaviouralEntity.numberOfComments])
I am not sure I like the deep inheritance hierarchy of
FAMIX. It seems
rather brittle. Is Delphi a special case?
FAMIX was first built in VW, and we only relied on single inheritance.
Since a long while we have the plan of moving towards Traits. More recently
Nicolas expressed an interest in working on such a topic, and Alain Plantec
extended Fame with the concept of Traits. However, until now, nothing
really moved but it would definitely be great to have more energy spent
there.
Cheers,
Doru
Stephan
_______________________________________________
Moose-dev mailing list
Moose-dev(a)iam.unibe.ch
https://www.iam.unibe.ch/mailman/listinfo/moose-dev
--
www.tudorgirba.com
"Every thing has its own flow"
8:44 a.m.
On 08/29/2013 06:56 AM, Tudor Girba wrote:
I am not sure I like the deep inheritance hierarchy of FAMIX. It
seems
rather brittle. Is Delphi a special case?
FAMIX was first built in VW, and we only relied on single inheritance.
Since a long while we have the plan of moving towards Traits. More
recently Nicolas expressed an interest in working on such a topic, and
Alain Plantec extended Fame with the concept of Traits. However, until
now, nothing really moved but it would definitely be great to have
more energy spent there.
Cheers,
Doru
It is still on my todo list, but I just don't have the time to do it.
nicolas
--
Nicolas Anquetil -- RMod research team (Inria)
3916
days inactive
3917
days old
2 comments
3 participants
participants (3)
-
Nicolas Anquetil -
Stephan Eggermont -
Tudor Girba