27 Mar
2007
27 Mar
'07
7:57 p.m.
Hello,
I am trying to figure out the design of the classes in Pier Blog. I am
wondering why PBBlog is a subclass of PRCase, and not a direct
subclass of PRStructure:
PRStructure #('parent' 'name' 'title' 'tags')
PRCase #('document')
PBBlog #('managingEditor' 'webMaster' 'copyright'
'language'
'itemCount'
'feedTitle' 'commentTimeout')
PBEntry #('uuid' 'author' 'publication')
PBComment #()
PBPost #('sourceUrl' 'sourceTitle' 'enclosure')
PRPage #()
PRComponent #('componentClass' 'settings')
PRFile #('file')
PRForm #('model' 'metamodel')
PRCase's class comment says:"I am an abstract class holding onto a
document definition representing the contents of the receiver. Most of
my subclasses will allow user to edit myself using the Wiki syntax."
I guess my question is: for an application that is similar to a blog
(managing a list of homogeneous entries, maybe nested), is it a good
idea to make it a direct subclass of PRStructure?
Matthias
27 Mar
27 Mar
9:06 p.m.
I am trying to figure out the design of the classes in
Pier Blog. I am
wondering why PBBlog is a subclass of PRCase, and not a direct
subclass of PRStructure:
I wanted to be able to put a longer description of the Blog.
PRStructure and all other subclasses except PRCase don't have an
attached document.
I guess my question is: for an application that is
similar to a blog
(managing a list of homogeneous entries, maybe nested), is it a good
idea to make it a direct subclass of PRStructure?
The decision if a PRStructure can be nested or not is orthogonal to
the functionality the class provides. The nesting is solely with the
PRChildren decoration that can be added and removed on demand, in
fact this happens behind the curtain. In SmallWiki this was different
and caused a lot of problems. By overriding #canBeChildOf: and
#canBeParentOf: you can control what can be nested into what else.
So the question to subclass PRStructure or PRCase is solely a
question if you need the parser, formatter and editor for the wiki
syntax.
aBoolean
ifTrue: [ PRCase ]
ifFalse: [ PRStructure ]
Cheers,
Lukas
--
Lukas Renggli
http://www.lukas-renggli.ch
11:15 p.m.
Lukas,
I wanted to be able to put a longer description of the
Blog.
PRStructure and all other subclasses except PRCase don't have an
attached document.
yeah, that's what I found out after writing the email :-)
The decision if a PRStructure can be nested or not is
orthogonal to
the functionality the class provides. The nesting is solely with the
PRChildren decoration that can be added and removed on demand, in
fact this happens behind the curtain. In SmallWiki this was different
and caused a lot of problems. By overriding #canBeChildOf: and
#canBeParentOf: you can control what can be nested into what else.
So the question to subclass PRStructure or PRCase is solely a
question if you need the parser, formatter and editor for the wiki
syntax.
That makes sense, thanks a lot!
Matthias
6250
days inactive
6250
days old
2 comments
2 participants
participants (2)
-
Lukas Renggli -
Matthias Berth